How are TBI Settlements Calculated?

Calculating traumatic brain injury (TBI) settlements involves assessing economic losses and non-economic damages. These cases require careful legal and medical analysis because the effects of a brain injury may not become visible immediately and may evolve. Therefore, a TBI lawyer can help ensure your claim is correctly valued.

Insurance companies may attempt to assign a dollar value based on formulaic models, whose estimates may not account for the broader impact on your life. This is one reason why working with a qualified attorney is foundational. A lawyer can ensure the settlement reflects the true cost of the injury. Without legal counsel, there's a high risk of accepting far less than the claim is worth.

Schedule a Free Consultation

Read on to learn more about how TBI settlements can pursue one effectively.

How Do People Sustain TBIs?

Traumati c brain injuries happen when a sudden impact or force hits the head, disrupting how the brain usually works. The sudden jolt, blow, or penetration to the head can lead to serious head injuries, including traumatic brain injuries.

Understand that even a minor TBI can escalate or persist for a long time, leading to lifelong implications.

Common causes of TBI include:

Motor Vehicle Collisions: Car, motorcycle, and truck accidents are among the leading causes of TBIs. Even with airbags and seatbelts, the impact force can cause the brain to shift violently within the skull, causing bruising, bleeding, or swelling.
Falls: Slips, trips, or falls, particularly from heights or on hard surfaces, are a major source of brain injuries. Older adults and workers in construction or industrial settings are especially vulnerable.
Workplace Accidents: Construction sites, warehouses, and factories expose workers to falling objects, machinery-related trauma, and other risks that can result in head injuries if safety protocols fail.
Physical Assaults: Acts of violence, such as blows to the head during an assault or domestic abuse, can cause direct trauma to the brain, sometimes without external signs of injury.
Sports Injuries: High-impact sports such as football, boxing, hockey, and cycling often cause concussions and more severe brain trauma, especially when players skip proper head protection or return to play too soon after an injury.
Explosions and Blasts: Those who work in hazardous environments may suffer TBIs from blast waves or flying debris. These injuries can be especially complex due to the combined effects of pressure, shrapnel, and psychological trauma.

These scenarios can lead to varying degrees of injury, from minor concussions to severe, life-altering brain damage. For instance, a car crash may cause a direct blow to the head, while a fall from a height can result in diffuse brain injury due to rapid acceleration or deceleration.

Retaining an attorney is essential in these cases, as they can investigate the cause of the injury, identify liable parties, and gather evidence to establish fault. Legal representation ensures you seek appropriate compensation to cover all the resulting losses.

What Is the Formula for Calculating the Settlement Amount?

No fixed formula is used in all traumatic brain injury (TBI) cases. Still, two widely applied methods help estimate a claim's value: the multiplier method and the per diem method. Each approach quantifies damages by assigning monetary value to financial and personal losses.

The Multiplier Method

This method begins by adding all quantifiable economic damages, such as healthcare expenses, loss of income, and out-of-pocket costs. That total is then multiplied by a number, usually between 1.5 and 5, to reflect the severity and long-term consequences of the injury.

For instance, a severe TBI with long-term cognitive impairment may warrant a higher multiplier, such as 4 or 5, while a more minor injury might use a lower multiplier, like 1 or 2. The resulting figure is added to the economic damages to estimate the total settlement.

However, choosing the correct multiplier is highly subjective and often contested by insurers. Your TBI lawyer can assemble medical documentation and professional testimony to justify a higher multiplier and counterattempts to minimize your claim’s value.

The Per Diem Method

This approach assigns a daily monetary amount to the pain, suffering, and limitations you endure. It multiplies that amount by how many days you expect to suffer from the injury’s effects. For example, a per diem of $250 over 1,000 days (just under three years) will total $250,000 in non-economic damages.

Insurers rarely agree to a per diem rate without challenge. A brain injury attorney can present a detailed timeline of your recovery, medical reports, and functional limitations to justify the rate and duration used in this calculation.

These methods provide a structured way to estimate compensation, but their effectiveness depends on a comprehensive assessment of the TBI’s impact. Legal representation applies these models with the right context to avoid minimizing your recovery. Without legal guidance, victims may accept inadequate offers that fail to account for the long-term consequences of a TBI.

Damages Recoverable in a Brain Injury Case

Traumatic brain injuries (TBIs) are often associated with serious financial and personal losses. A TBI claim divides your potential compensation into economic, non-economic, and, in some cases, punitive damages. Each category serves a different purpose: to make you whole again or to address misconduct. These damages fall into three categories, as explained below:

Economic Damages

These pertain to quantifiable financial setbacks resulting from the injury you sustained. They include the following:

Medical Expenses: Includes emergency care, hospitalization, surgeries, rehabilitation, cognitive therapy, medications, and any future medical treatment related to the brain injury.
Lost Income: If the injured person cannot return to work or must cut hours, they may receive compensation for lost wages and reduced future earning capacity.
Out-of-Pocket Costs: These may include travel to medical appointments, home modifications (such as wheelchair ramps), assistive devices, and other injury-related expenses.

Thorough documentation, such as medical bills, employment records, and economic expert projections, supports these losses. A TBI attorney compiles and presents this evidence to secure full recovery of past expenses and future needs.

Non-Economic Damages

These damages compensate for subjective, non-financial impacts individuals may experience due to various circumstances. They involve the following challenges:

Pain and Suffering: Chronic pain, trouble with cognitive function, and emotional distress caused by the injury.
Loss of Enjoyment of Life: When the harm prevents you from engaging in activities you once enjoyed or affects your relationships.
Emotional Distress: Depression, anxiety, mood swings, and other psychological issues can arise from trauma.
Loss of Consortium: Where companionship or marital support is lost, a spouse may recover such damages.

These elements can be difficult to quantify, which is why insurers often undervalue them. A lawyer builds this portion of the claim through personal statements, professional testimony, and medical assessments illustrating how deeply the injury has disrupted day-to-day living.

Punitive Damages

Courts award punitive damages in extreme cases of serious negligence or intentional wrongdoing. For example, punitive damages may apply if a driver is drunk or a company knowingly ignores a safety issue. These damages punish those who commit gross misconduct and discourage similar actions in the future.

To formulate a robust settlement demand, you must consider every category of damages. Without legal counsel, you risk overlooking or insufficiently claiming specific categories, especially non-economic and punitive damages.

Should I Accept a Traumatic Brain Injury Settlement?

Deciding whether or not to sign a settlement offer for a TBI claim is a significant decision that requires careful consideration of the injury’s immediate and long-term consequences. You should never make this decision in haste. Once you sign a settlement agreement, you lose the right to pursue further compensation, even if new complications arise later. Given the long-term and sometimes unpredictable nature of brain injuries, it’s important to ensure the settlement fully accounts for current and future losses.

Insurance companies often present early settlement offers to resolve claims quickly, offers that may not fully account for the extensive impacts of a TBI. Before accepting any offer, thoroughly evaluate factors like the injury’s severity, ongoing medical needs, and impact on daily life. A qualified attorney is essential, as they can assess the settlement's fairness, identify all potential damages, and negotiate to ensure the compensation aligns with the victim’s current and future needs.

Before accepting any settlement offer, a TBI attorney should review your case to help determine whether the offer covers the following:

All necessary medical treatment, both past, ongoing, and anticipated
Lost income and reduced future earning capacity
Pain, suffering, and reduced quality of life
Long-term support needs, such as in-home care or vocational retraining

Accepting a TBI settlement without legal guidance risks locking you into an agreement that fails to address ongoing or future challenges. An attorney brings the knowledge needed to critically evaluate offers, counter lowball tactics, and pursue maximum compensation through negotiation or litigation. With a lawyer, you ensure your move is informed and aligns with your long-term well-being in safeguarding your financial and personal recovery.

How Long Does It Take to Settle a TBI Case?

The timeline for resolving a traumatic brain injury (TBI) case can vary significantly, depending on the nature of the injury, the strength of the evidence, and the willingness of the involved parties to negotiate. Some claims may settle within a few months, while others can take a year or longer, especially if litigation becomes necessary.

One major factor is achieving medical stability. Settlements usually shouldn’t be finalized until the full extent of the injury is understood, also known as maximum medical improvement. That means waiting until a doctor can provide a clear prognosis, which may take several months or even longer in cases of moderate to severe TBI. If you settle too soon, it may result in an amount that doesn’t cover future care because it fails to reflect how the injury will affect your long-term functioning, independence, and earning ability.

Other factors that may affect the timeline of your TBI case include:

Disputes over liability: If the at-fault party denies responsibility, they may stall the process while gathering evidence.
Multiple liable parties: Sorting out who is legally and financially responsible can delay negotiations.
Insurance negotiations: Insurers may drag out discussions in hopes of reducing the payout.
The need for professional evaluation: Medical professionals, vocational specialists, and economists may need time to prepare reports that support your claim.

An attorney can keep the process moving while protecting you from being pressured into a premature or undervalued settlement. Legal representation ensures the insurer doesn’t control the timeline but that your best interests and full medical recovery guide the process. With a lawyer advocating for you, the focus stays on achieving fair compensation rather than rushing to close the claim.

How To Maximize Your Brain Injury Settlement

Maximizing a traumatic brain injury (TBI) settlement depends on taking deliberate steps that strengthen your legal claim and protect its value. Insurance companies often rely on inconsistencies, delays, or incomplete records to reduce payouts. The more thorough and strategic your actions are, your position will be stronger during negotiations or in court.

Here are key actions that support the full value of your case:

Report the case to the proper authorities immediately
Seek medical attention without delay and continue all recommended care
Follow every medical instruction and attend all follow-up appointments
Keep detailed records of expenses, treatment, and daily challenges
Obtain and keep a copy of the police or incident report
Avoid posting anything about your injury or recovery on social media
Do not provide a recorded statement to any insurance representative
Do not sign any insurance forms or releases without legal advice
Decline the first settlement offer without proper legal evaluation
Consult a brain injury attorney before making any settlement decisions

Discuss Your Case with a TBI Lawyer Immediately

The most important step in calculating your TBI settlement properly is to speak with a lawyer. A TBI attorney can properly value your claim, protect your interests throughout the process, and hold the responsible party accountable under the law.

If you hire a lawyer on time, they can provide the structure and strategy to pursue meaningful compensation. Acting early gives you the best chance to build a strong case and secure the recovery you deserve. Speak with your brain injury lawyer today to determine your case's worth.

Christopher C. Walton

Managing Partner

Christopher C. Walton is the founder of Walton Law APC, an award-winning law firm with offices located in Southern California and Western Washington. After spending several years defending insurance companies, he now dedicates his practice exclusively to representing plaintiffs in the areas of personal injury, employment law, and nursing home neglect.

Author's Bio